A report commissioned by the Wellcome Trust focusing on the present state and the future of peer review was published last month. The goal of the report was “to examine the current landscape of peer review for research publications, including recent innovations and how they have worked in practice; and to gather and appraise the views of publishers and others as to how systems and processes may change over the next four to five years.” The report focused on six key areas of likely development in the near future:
- Acknowledgement of the need to have greater transparency and openness in the review process;
- Agreement on the desirability of greater interaction between editors, reviewers and authors;
- Utilization by publishers of more innovative article-level metrics, such as Altmetric, Plum Analytics, and Impact Story;
- Increasing interest in the provision of rewards in the form of scholarly credit and recognition for reviewers;
- Desirability to improve guidance, training and feedback for reviewers;
- Growing interest in distinguishing between the different purposes of peer review.
The full report.